Live Q&A: Rates, War, Zestimates, Points & Inheriting a Home

Every Wednesday, real estate broker Jeb Smith and mortgage advisor Josh Lewis go live to answer whatever the audience throws at them: mortgages, home prices, negotiating, timing, all of it. The September 3, 2026 show opened with mortgage rates climbing to their highest level since June 2025, then moved into listener questions. This recap pulls out the questions worth keeping and rewrites the answers so they stand on their own.

Below you'll find their take on how the war with Iran pushes rates around, whether to pay for points to lower your rate, which home-value websites to trust, whether to list now or wait for spring, whether you can beat a builder's in-house lender offer, and the popular idea that a whole generation will inherit homes instead of buying them. Each answer starts with the bottom line, then explains the reasoning.

Stop guessing what you can really afford

It starts with a Discovery Call, a straight conversation about your real numbers. Josh and his team show you the price range and loan options that fit, and map out every step to closing. They handle your loan directly, never a referral, so you tour with confidence and write offers sellers take seriously.

Build my Roadmap →

Why are mortgage rates surging right now?

Rates are climbing because the market is worried inflation isn't beaten and that the Fed may hold or even raise its policy rate. The biggest push came out of the Fed's Jackson Hole symposium, where the message landed as hawkish: the Fed made clear it hasn't given up on its 2% inflation target, called this summer's better inflation readings an aberration rather than a real trend, and signaled it won't hand the market forward guidance to trade on.

On top of that, oil prices are higher on renewed conflict in the Middle East, which feeds straight into inflation. After that week, the odds of a rate hike at the next meeting flipped from roughly 35% to about 62% (as of 9/3/2026). Josh's read: a hike at this point could actually be good for mortgage rates, because the market's bigger fear was a Fed that cuts regardless of the data. The ten-year yield moved from about 4.62% to nearly 4.80% in a week, which is a real move but not a violent one given how much bad news stacked up. That suggests a near-term ceiling over the next three to six months, but a real trend change needs something to break: peace with Iran, lower oil, softer inflation, or a weaker jobs report.

Back to all questions

How does the war with Iran affect mortgage interest rates?

The war pushes rates higher two ways, both tied to supply. First, oil. If the conflict threatens the flow of oil through the Strait of Hormuz, that cuts the supply of a commodity the whole world needs while demand barely moves. Higher oil is inflationary, and inflation drives bond yields and mortgage rates up. One detail Josh watches: the correlation is even tighter with diesel, because diesel moves nearly everything to market, so the cost trickles into food, clothing, and transportation.

Second, borrowing. The U.S. spends more than it takes in, so financing an expensive war means issuing more bonds. A bigger supply of bonds against a finite pool of buyers means the government has to offer higher yields, and mortgage rates follow. Until those dynamics ease, both forces keep upward pressure on rates.

Back to all questions

Which home-value estimate is most accurate: Zillow, Redfin, or something else?

Treat all of them as a rough tool, not a real number. These estimates are algorithms comparing bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage, and maybe lot size against nearby sales. What they can't see is condition, quality of upgrades, position on the street, noise, views, or whether a nearby comp sits on a land lease or in a very different community. Jeb has watched these numbers snap to match a new list price within a day or two of a home hitting the market, which tells you how easily they're influenced.

They're most reliable in a uniform setting, like a condo community or planned development where units are genuinely similar and there are recent comparable sales. Everywhere else, look at the property's own sale history, estimate the area's annual appreciation, and do some back-of-the-napkin math. Better yet, talk to a local agent who actually knows the market and can walk the property. A photo can't tell you a flip was done poorly; a walkthrough can. On the newer Kelley Blue Book home index, Josh's skepticism is about the pitch: an ad bragging that its number is higher than Zillow's isn't the same as being more accurate.

Back to all questions

Should I pay points to buy down my mortgage rate?

For most buyers, no. Points are voluntarily prepaying interest. Every lender has a par (zero-point) rate, and if you want a lower rate they charge you upfront for the interest they'd give up over the life of the loan. As a rough rule of thumb, one point (1% of the loan) buys about a quarter-percent lower rate. So on a $500,000 loan, dropping the rate half a percent costs roughly two points, or about $10,000, to save somewhere around $170 to $180 a month.

That puts your breakeven at roughly 56 to 59 months, so nearly five years before you come out ahead, and that's before accounting for what the $10,000 could earn sitting in a high-yield savings account, which pushes breakeven out further. If rates drop or you sell within those years, you never recoup it. There are exceptions: you're about to retire and won't qualify for a mortgage again, or a divorce means an income is leaving and this is your last shot to finance. For those cases points can make sense. For most people, keep the cash. Whether points fit your situation is exactly the kind of math worth running before you commit.

Back to all questions

Should I list my home now or wait until spring?

It depends on your market and whether you actually need to move. In a tight-supply market like parts of the Northeast, now can still be a good time to list. In softer Southern markets like much of Texas and Florida, waiting may make more sense. In a market like Orange County, if there's no specific need to sell, it's reasonable to start talking about the spring.

The catch is you know what today's market looks like; you don't know what February or March brings. Rates could be higher, inventory could be larger, and spring could turn out worse than right now. So unless you're chasing a specific goal, let your real situation and your read on rates drive the decision, not a guess about a better season. If you believe rates will be higher next year and you're planning to sell and buy again, that's a reason to move sooner. Jeb's own view is less that rates rise next year and more that they aren't going anywhere in the short run, and a six-handle rate by spring looks unlikely unless something breaks, and breaking usually isn't good news.

Back to all questions

Find out if you're actually ready to buy, in 2 minutes

Most buyers wait months longer than they need to, just because no one ever told them they were ready. Answer a few quick questions and get a straight read: where you stand today, what's holding you back, and the fastest path to your own front door. Free, no call, no credit check.

Get my readiness score →

Can I beat a builder's in-house lender offering $20,000 toward closing costs and buying down my rate?

No, and it isn't free money. When a builder's own mortgage company hands you $20,000, they're choosing to lose it on the loan because they're making a healthy margin on the house itself. It's all publicly traded, so you can see it. Gross margins on new-home sales have compressed as builders lean on these concessions, in some cases down to roughly 19%, meaning about 19 cents of every sale dollar reaches the bottom line after they hand you the incentive.

The thing to watch is what the incentives don't change: the price. Builders would rather buy down your rate or cover closing costs than cut the sticker, because a lower recorded price hurts values across the community and future phases. Price is the one number you can't fix later, so weigh that against a rate buydown you might refinance away.

Back to all questions

Why doesn't the government just become a lender and offer first-time buyers a lower rate?

Because it would cost money we don't have and would backfire on affordability. The country already carries roughly $40 trillion in debt, so there's no free pool of cash to fund subsidized mortgages. That's the first problem.

The second is economics. Cheaper financing helps the first people through the door, but it juices demand. With supply already at historically low levels, more demand pushes prices up, so you'd be running uphill trying to keep payments affordable for an asset there isn't enough of. As Ed Pinto of the American Enterprise Institute's housing center has put it, government policy is good at boosting demand and poor at increasing supply, and this is a supply problem. Some would argue FHA, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac already subsidize borrowing and are part of why prices are high; a bigger program on top of that would make affordability worse, not better.

Back to all questions

Is my generation really more likely to inherit a home than buy one?

More people will inherit homes than would have otherwise, but the fatalistic version, that most people will inherit instead of buy, isn't supported by the numbers. A large wealth transfer is coming over the next 15 or so years, and there's real truth that some who inherit wouldn't otherwise have become owners, plus more parents and grandparents gifting or selling homes to family at a discount.

What that transfer probably won't do is flood the market with cheap inventory. Jeb's view is that many heirs keep the property precisely because they wouldn't otherwise own, so those homes never list. Josh sees the same pattern in his loan pipeline: heirs often keep the house and take out a mortgage to pay off the small remaining balance and buy out the other heirs, rather than selling. High-cost metros like the Bay Area, Southern California, and the Northeast create real geographic squeezes, and concentrated retirement communities are their own story. But Josh's book of business is full of buyers in their late twenties to early forties with good jobs and good credit who are buying today. Buyers aren't disappearing.

Back to all questions

How are rents tracking compared to home prices lately? I heard rents have gone down.

Rents are down, but far less than many people assume. Realtor.com's latest rental report at the time showed asking rents down about 0.8% year over year and up 0.1% month over month, the 36th straight month of year-over-year declines, leaving rents roughly 3.9% below the 2022 peak in nominal terms (as of early September 2026).

Adjust for inflation and the picture is more meaningful. With three-plus percent inflation each of the past three years, rents are down closer to 15% in real terms from the peak. That means more affordable than three years ago, not affordable. On the ground it's mixed: some landlords hold rents flat to keep good tenants, others push 3% to 4% increases. Josh, who manages two of his own rentals, has traded a modest rent increase for a signed two-year lease, because a vacancy, turnover, and re-listing cost real money, and tenants weigh moving costs the same way.

Back to all questions

What tools does the Fed have besides raising or cutting rates to control inflation?

Really just two levers, and both work slowly. The first is the policy rate. Hiking makes money more expensive, which cools economic activity over time and eventually brings inflation down, but the response is lagged, not immediate.

The second is the balance sheet. The Fed can buy bonds, either Treasuries to influence rates broadly or mortgage-backed securities to target mortgage rates specifically, which is what it did during COVID. Buying takes supply out of the market so the buyers who need bonds bid prices up and push yields down. Beyond those two mechanisms it gets complex and into the weeds, but those are the primary tools, and neither is fast.

Back to all questions

The recent BLS jobs report came in very negative, so why have interest rates been rising since?

Because right now the Fed is more focused on inflation than employment, and it also believes the labor market is stronger than it actually is. A weak jobs report is generally good for mortgage rates, but until inflation is under control, that softness may not move things much.

The deeper issue is how the Fed reads the data. Labor force participation has fallen sharply, so even though hiring has been anemic, the unemployment rate stays very low. Historically, unemployment this low has been inflationary, so the Fed sees risk where the headline job growth numbers keep coming in soft. New York Fed president John Williams said the day of the show he views the labor market as solid and thinks higher yields reflect strong economic growth rather than inflation fears. Josh's pushback: the growth that exists is concentrated in AI, data centers, and tech, so there's very little breadth. Parts of the economy are growing strongly while the labor market is not, which leaves the picture genuinely muddy.

Back to all questions

Get your toughest question answered by a lender and an agent, free

Every week we answer real buyer questions live, on the spot. Bring the one that's keeping you up at night, or send it ahead if you can't make it and we'll cover it on air. We go live every Wednesday at 5pm PT / 8pm ET on YouTube, with the replay on Spotify.

Submit a question →Watch live →